patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Baltusrol to Join Business Improvement District

Famed golf club to be part of self-financed business improvement effort.

 

A year after the formation of the Springfield Business Improvement District, one of Springfield’s most prominent businesses is set to join it.

Earlier this month, representatives of the Business Improvement district told the Springfield Township Committee that the Baltusrol Golf Club would soon be a BID member. The famed golf club was left out of the BID’s list of participating businesses after debate among officials and business owners.

The business improvement district was established in August of 2010, and is headed by Beth Lippman, who has run similar efforts in Livingston and Pompton Lakes. Under the terms of the BID, businesses in the district collectively pay for improvements, promotions and maintenance for all three of Springfield’s major shopping districts: the Morris Ave. downtown area, Mountain Ave. and route 22.

Baltusrol, founded in 1895, is one of the highest rated private golf courses in America. It hosted the PGA Championship in 2005 and is set to host it again in 2016.

The golf course was one of few commercial businesses exempt from the BID. While several current and former Springfield elected officials were hesitant to add Baltusrol to the group, BID representatives said that business owners felt it was unfair that the high-profile and lucrative golf club was excluded. BID Executive Director Beth Lippman said the vote to include Baltusrol in the BID was unanimous.

Discussing Baltusrol inclusion into the BID at a Township Committee meeting earlier this month, Springfield Mayor Ziad Shehady expressed support for the club’s membership in the business coalition.

“They are a commercial property and they are on the [tax] rolls as a commercial property,” Shehady said. 

Former Mayor Sy Mullman worried that if required to join the BID, Baltusrol might be discouraged from its charitable outreach to the town, including the annual Mayor’s Day Golf outing for Dayton students. Township Committee member Richard Huber expressed concerns about the township being a “good neighbor” to Baltrusol.

As a BID member, Baltusrol will be responsible for the annual fee supporting the BID. Previously, BID members said, Baltusrol’s management had expressed support for the BID and pledged to make two donations, one for each of the years the BID has existed, neither of which ultimately materialized. BID chairman Mike Scalera said that Baltrusol would be responsible for $30,000 annually as BID members.

“They didn’t remember agreeing to the donations,” Lippman said.

Lippman has spearheaded business improvement efforts in Livingston, Pompton Lakes and other municipalities. She said that golf courses in those towns have paid into their BIDs.

Baltrusol did not respond to requests for comment. 

  • Should Baltusrol be included in the BID?

    (Voting has been closed for this question)
    • Yes. They are a business in town and there shouldn't be exceptions
        6 (75%)
    • No. They are a unique enterprise that reaches out to the community on its own.
        2 (25%)
    Total votes: 8
  • Your vote will only count once. This is not a scientific poll. View Results Vote!
Related Topics: Business Improvement District, Golf Course, Springfield BID, and baltusrol

Lou

9:12 am on Friday, September 28, 2012

The business improvement needs to happen! Seeing what was done in Livingston it would be a huge win. The Morris Avenue district especially needs this, the buildingings are ill placed and unkept except for a select few. There seems to be nothing but a few long standing businesses and perpetually vacant locations.

Reply
Comment_arrow

BART FRAENKEL

11:33 am on Friday, September 28, 2012

It would be great to see the downtown developed, but, for the most part,the business owners aren't the property owners and they're the ones who need to buy into the project. If they don't it becomes very difficult to accomplish. And while Livingston sure looks good, the housing units haven't sold/rented as expected and there's been a big turnover of retailers. It's primarily the economy that's caused this, but we're in the same situation. The BID is a very good idea but it will probably take quite a few years before we get to see any kind of real change downtown.

Heather Krieger

9:41 am on Friday, September 28, 2012

I moved to springfield almost 3 years ago and live near the Morris Avenue district. Coming from NYC, I was excited to be within walking distance to commercial businesses, hoping for a coffee shope, yoga studio, market etd., but I was immediately disappointed at the shuttered businesses and disrepair of the buildings. The BID efforts may encourage me not to sell and move elsewhere, as up to this point, we have been looking for a way out of town. I want my family to have a town to be proud of and aesthetically, Springfield is an eyesore. Hopefully we'll see changes soon!!!

Reply

Jim Shamrock

1:48 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012

Heather, I totally agree!! You do have the Overpriced NYSports fitness in the shopping center but otherwise nothing but little take out stores, empty store fronts and gives the appearance of a run down town for anyone going thru town on bus or via car.

Reply

Jim Shamrock

1:51 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012

I do have to give a "shout out" for McGlynn's Irish pub/restaurant which still does great business despite its location. :)
Great Irish Food Fare and American Cuisine as well!

Reply

bob groder

6:11 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012

i get no break from my tax obligation as a springfield citizen and i could care less how prestigious baltusrol is. they owe just like any other business. case closed. if they dont like it thats just the way of the world of taxes. i dont like taxes noone does but i do pay my fair share. noone should be exempt from taxes no matter what the excuse.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Shane Ronan

5:07 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

They were previously exempted because they otherwise participate in fundraisers for the town, and it was feared that if the town required them to be part of the B.I.D. they would stop participating in these activities. This is no different then a company like Google or Amazon receiving tax exemptions to put offices in certain states or a business being given a tax exemption to prevent them from moving out of New Jersey.

Marilyn Eisenberg

10:56 pm on Friday, September 28, 2012

Marilyn Eisenberg
I have lived in Springfield 21 years, and always wished we had more of a town or village atmosphere such as Maplewood, Summit. It is though very important the residents of our town would support the business.
So many of the smaller stores on Mountain Ave. have come and gone.
Hopefully we will see improvements start to take place in the near future.

Reply

BART FRAENKEL

12:56 am on Saturday, September 29, 2012

The question shouldn't be whether or not Baltusrol should be part of the BID, it should be why weren't they included from the start.

Reply

BART FRAENKEL

7:39 am on Saturday, September 29, 2012

For the purpose of clarification, would Mr. Fernandez please post an explanation of how the money for the BID is raised? I mention him since Shehady stated that he spearheaded the program. If one of the other TC members or even Ms. Lippman wants to, that's fine. But the public should know where the money will come from so they can understand the process.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Shane Ronan

5:00 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

It's been well documented on this site, where the money comes from. Why are you trying to stir up controversy by asking a question that two minutes of searching on the term "Business Improvement District" would have answered? The previous posts also document the support of Business Improvement District by Deputy Mayor Fernandez.

http://springfield.patch.com/articles/downtown-special-improvement-district-plans-detailed

http://springfield.patch.com/articles/township-committee-hears-concerns-over-business-improvement-district

BART FRAENKEL

7:25 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Shane, you are playing the role of good soldier very well for the mayor. It's interesting that whenever the posts of those accused of being Shehady (Anthony D, B Freeman, etc.) don't appear for a while you to post a response that sounds very much like theirs. Well, at least you do it under your own name, I'll give you credit for that. But in regard to my post, there are many people who read this particular article and didn't know about the previous information and aren't as technologically adept to try and retrieve that info. I didn't think my question was out of line and was just asking for additional information, so don't read into things just because I post them. Unless there's a reason to be concerned with explaining how the BID works.
The simple answer to where the money comes from is that it is through specific tax paid by the businesses in the BID areas.
The problem I have with the BID is businesses are having a tough enough time these days and they'll end up just passing along the cost to their customers, which means the public will end up paying for it in the end. And Baltusrol does make scholarship donations, but most of it is from the Mayor's Day tournament and that's after they charge about $400 per person to play. Most businesses in town would probably be willing to give out scholarships under the same type of scenario. For as much as I like Baltusrol, they shouldn't get special treatment or be excluded from the BId.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Shane Ronan

8:00 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

I'm not anyone's soldier, anymore then the Springfield Democrats on the Township Committee are loyal subjects of Mr. Bergen. To be clear, I've NEVER posted under a name other then my own, or posted on someone else's behalf, as much as you might like to insinuate that. I call things like I see them, and as I see you attempt to agitate people against the Springfield Republicans at every turn.

You don't have to be technologically adept to perform a simple search. If you are capable of logging into the Patch and posting, I'd venture to say you should be able to perform a simple search, by typing in the search term in the box.

As for the BID, it has bi-partisan support, in fact the only person to vote against it on LAST YEARS TC, under Mayor Keffer was Mr. Krauss, although I don't know the specifics of why.

Keep in mind, most business owners in Springfield don't own the properties they operate out of, they have leases on properties owned by someone else. So it's not the the businesses that are getting hit with this tax, it's their landlords, the property owners. And since they have leases, there rents aren't automatically increased. In fact, given the current rate of vacancy in Springfield, I'd find it hard to believe that ANY landlord could raise rents even at lease renewal. That's simple economics, supply and demand.

I'd venture to guess that neither of us knows exactly how much Baltusrol donates or contributes to anyone, so discussing it further is pure conjecture.

Joey D

8:50 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Look what they did to the echo plaza. That place was empty for years, including the office building. A new company purchased the property, fixed it up at now it's thriving. Even with a bad economy. I am tired of the excuses or being told we will never a have center like Westfield , Millburn or Summit. We should have better. The residents have been crying for it for years and nothing. Enough of the excuses ! Tear it all down and do it better then anybody else ! Just do it !

Reply

BART FRAENKEL

9:24 am on Monday, October 1, 2012

Shane, you're smart enough to know that when the property owners incur additional costs they will simply pass it along to their tenants, and the public ultimately gets to foot the bill on one level or another. As you said, simple economics dictates things, so if the property owners are going to have to pay more then in order to maintain the same level of income they will have to charge more just to break even. The BID process is a tax on the property owners pure and simple. I'm not saying its a bad way of addressing this, but let's be fair and call it what it is. And given the amount of money that will be collected, even if Baltusrol were to pay $30,000 themselves, it will take a long time to accrue enough money to make a difference downtown.
I have always believed the answer was to encourage the property owners to invest in their properties with the ability to build another 2 floors higher so they could generate additional revenue and make their investment worthwhile. The TC was very close to doing that in 2008 before the economy collapsed. Without the economic collapse, I honestly believe we would have seen progress by now.

Reply

Leave a comment

 

The Springfield Patch
Valentine's Shopping Guide

See the full guide!

Patch Picks